Posts on Martha’s Vineyard Travel Tips contain affiliate links from various programs and as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. When you buy through links on this site I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. See Privacy Policy for more information
Popular Restaurants Serving Thanksgiving Dinner On Martha’s Vineyard
Spending Thanksgiving on the island but don’t know where to eat? Already known for its vibrant culinary scene, Thanksgiving dinner on Martha’s Vineyard is a great opportunity to dine with the family without the stress of cooking at home.
Local restaurants usually serve up traditional fare with a creative twist. From fresh seafood and locally sourced vegetables to classic turkey and stuffing, there is something for every palate.
It can be pretty close to the day before restaurants announce their menus so check back regularly for updates!
Restaurants open for Thanksgiving dinner on Martha’s Vineyard
1. 2025 Thanksgiving Dinner at Bettini at the Harbor view Hotel, Edgartown
The Harbor View Hotel invites guests to savor a memorable Thanksgiving at Bettini Restaurant with a curated four-course dinner featuring seasonal and holiday classics, as well as fresh seafood options.
Kick off your meal with an appetizer of either shrimp bisque with a sherry creme fraiche and crisp leeks or some autumn greens with pear, pomegranate, toasted hazelnuts and a honey & thyme vinaigrette.
The second course continues the autumnal theme with some warm bay scallops or a butternut squash & apple risotto.
Entrées are thoughtfully crafted, with options like citrus-baked cod, herb-crusted prime beef tenderloin, or a roasted heirloom turkey complete with traditional brioche stuffing and cranberry relish.
Sides are served family-style and include holiday favorites such as roasted Brussels sprouts, candied sweet potatoes, and chive mashed potatoes.
End your meal on a sweet note with a choice of pumpkin spiced creme brulee with a dried fruit compote or sticky toffee pudding with plum preserves and salted caramel. As you dine, enjoy panoramic views of Edgartown Harbor and the iconic lighthouse.
Dinner is served from 12:00 PM to 7:00 PM at $180 per adult and $90 for children under 12. Reservations are essential and can be made on OpenTable or by calling 508-627-3761.
2. 2025 Thanksgiving dinner at The Black Dog Tavern, Vineyard Haven
The Black Dog Tavern is offering a cozy, family-style Thanksgiving dinner with all the comforts of a homemade holiday meal and beautiful views of Vineyard Haven Harbor.
The menu includes a choice of clam chowder or pumpkin bisque to start, followed by a hearty spread featuring fresh herb-roasted turkey, house-made bread stuffing, mashed potatoes, sweet corn, green beans, and more.
Guests can end the meal with a slice of bakery-made pie, choosing from pecan, pumpkin, or apple.
Dinner is served on Thanksgiving Day, November 27th, with seatings at 11:30 AM, 1:30 PM, 3:30 PM, and 5:30 PM. The meal is $90 per adult and $40 for children 12 and under, with reservations limited to 90 minutes per seating.
Book your spot by calling The Black Dog Tavern at 508-693-9223, as seats fill quickly for this cherished island tradition.
Final words: Thanksgiving dinner on Martha’s Vineyard
In addition to the delectable cuisine, there are so many events in November on Martha’s Vineyard to enjoy! Earn your dinner with a morning turkey trot, visit a pop-up holiday gift shop or say hi to Santa at the 2-day, Light Up Oak Bluffs event.
Thanksgiving dinner on Martha’s Vineyard is a chance to experience the farm-to-table ethos of the local restaurants. Enjoy your holiday!
Related posts:
- Martha’s Vineyard Travel Guide
- Martha’s Vineyard in October: 19 Reasons Fall is a Great Time to Visit
- Martha’s Vineyard in December: 16 Festive Reasons to visit in Winter
- 23 Best Martha’s Vineyard Gifts: Holiday Gift Guide
- Martha’s Vineyard in November: 20 fun off-season activities
- 5 Best family restaurants in Martha’s Vineyard for easy dining with kids
- Edgartown Travel Tips: Making the most of your visit
